8. Questions 2 and 3
From "The Questions of Raisin and Chick"
in the holy writings of the Cult of Song
Mother, why do death and pain pursue us until
separation breaks us?
The song of all sings a
note, a beautiful note
that you would hear forever, but then follows another,
just as beautiful
and the former one fades, until you hear it no more.
I do not know all. I only
can listen to the
song. Arm came to us because it is possible that IS
might die. If IS may
die, then what in the universe is eternal?
If there is a reason why we
die even though
we would sing forever, I do not know it.
Mother, if we do not know the reason for our dying,
how can we know
the reason for our living?
We cannot, dear Chick. Where
in the songs of
IS is there a sound or a word that gives the reason
for living? It is a
gift, to sing with IS. I know I am awake when I hear
the singing, for then
I am the song I hear, and the song has always been as
long as there was
awakening. It will remain as long as anyone remains
I know not from where the
gift comes nor do
I know its purpose. I only know that when I sing with
IS, then I am I.
And when we all sing together in our chapel, then we
are all great and
loving. Then all pain is raised into loveliness, and
all sorrow into harmony.
9. Ram at the Gates
As the sun set
over the western sands, a blaze of red-gold in the
dust beneath a glowing
blue that faded rapidly toward the east into violet
and almost black in
the dry, clear air at the edge of the waste land, Ram
always grew lonely.
That was the only thing he disliked about his work.
Loneliness was one
of the reasons he drank himself to sleep each night.
And it was partly
because he drank himself to sleep that he screamed
with such abandon the
morning he saw a monster in his hut.
He enjoyed working
alone, with no bossman always at his shoulder
commenting on each move,
as if a big-belly's job in life was to wear him like a
glove that did all
the work in the dirt and took all the blows and heat
and thirst, while
the hand, comfortable inside, thought itself the soul
and lived on the
bright blood from the heart. Each day he would open
one of the seven gates,
sending the water coursing through one of the main
irrigation canals that
fed a system of ditches and fields in the fertile soil
here at the flat
edge of the desert.
There was a dam
at the end of Marsh River, thirty feet high and thirty
feet wide at the
top. Out of the middle of the dam came a stream that
was all of Marsh River
that remained free. The stream spilled from the lake
over a stone trough,
when there was enough water, and fed a small lake at
the base of the hills.
From the two ends of the dam ran large ditches paved
with stones. These
stone canals ran out of the hills and far across the
flat land. One ran
east, another west. The west canal, for which Ram was
to the southeast at the base of the hills. Ram's job
was to regulate the
seven gates that opened from this canal. Each gate was
to be opened for
a day and a night, and during that day, he was to
follow the water along
its course to make sure all the ditches worked as they
should. If there
was a problem too large to fix himself, he was to run
a large red flag
up the pole next to his hut. When all was well, a
green flag flew there.
Mostly he worked a little with his spade, packing dirt
into places where
the water washed through the stones in the main
ditches, or piling and
packing dirt where banks had eroded. And he walked.
His main work was walking
from dawn to late afternoon, in the shade of the wide
hat that kept his
almost bald head from baking and his dark-skinned
shoulders from burning
and peeling under the intense sun. He carried his
spade and in a shoulder
bag, a bottle of clean water dipped from the canal at
the gate, and some
dried fruit and bread for his midday meal.
It was hot work
for it almost never rained here in the growing season,
and there was rarely
a cloud cover. When he returned at the end of the day,
his white tunic
and pantaloons would be stained only with dust that he
could beat out if
he wished. But he always jumped into the canal, after
taking off his goat-leather
shoes, and as he bathed, he would remove his now
washed clothes, laying
them on the rocks to dry. He would sing at the top of
his lungs, all alone
with no one around for miles, and that's when he would
begin to feel lonely.
By the time he walked naked from the canal to his hut,
he would be nearly
dry again. By the time he put on his change of clothes
and returned to
the canal, his freshly washed clothes would be nearly
dry again, ready
to hang on the pegs next to the open window of his hut
where they would
finish drying and airing in the night.
The hut itself,
though small, was comfortable, a single room, with a
packed sand floor
covered with mats. He had shuttered windows on three
sides, his door on
the fourth. The hut was built of poles and planks,
four poles sunk into
the ground forming the main frame. There was a plank
roof that let in sun,
air, and dust, and made the hut unlivable in the
infrequent rains of the
wet season, though then no one stayed here, there
being no work then in
the grain fields of the desert. Then the hut stood
open, the mats hung
on the wall pegs so as to dry quickly if they got wet.
Inside he had a
feather-stuffed mattress, high shelves for his things,
pegs for his clothing
and tools, a table, and one tight cabinet where he
could store his food.
There was a stool that usually sat outside, next to
the door, where in
the evening he would lean against the rough planking
with his bottle.
Hot but pleasant
work by day and loneliness in the evening were the
causes of Ram's thirst.
Each seven days, he would return to Marshtown, for two
nights of rest,
and when he came back to his hut in the fields, he
would carry a great
load, not only his food for the week, but also his
bottles, rattling faintly
in his heavy pack. The bottles contained his liquor,
and this is what satisfied
his thirst as night drew on and no family or
companions came to sit with
him before his door, to sing songs or tell tales or
recite the news of
He gave himself
a bottle each night -- like a baby in its cradle, he
told himself -- and
when it was finished, he drifted off into a dreamless
sleep. Before he
could eat in the morning, he would return to the
canal, fall to his knees,
and plunge his head into the water, warm but still
bracing. Having rinsed
his mouth, he would shake the water from his brown
hair and his tight curled
accumulating beard of red and gold -- he shaved in
Marshtown -- and then
he would open the day's gate, close yesterday's gate,
and return to the
hut to have his breakfast and begin the day's work.
Ram had watched
over this part of the irrigation system since the
newer of the two main
canals was finished, for six years now. His body and
mind had adjusted
to the routine, and except for the rare major break in
a ditch, the work
went on the same from day to day until the end of the
growing season, when
he would return to his crazy sister in Marshtown, to
spend the cool, rainy
season among his friends, taking his ease, tending his
and helping with the house. In the town, he drank with
his friends in their
homes over games or at the pub, and though he too
often drank too much,
he left behind for a few months -- almost without
noticing -- his regular
At the usual
times, teams of workers would come to the fields, to
prepare and plant
the ground, and a few times to weed. Before the
harvest, his work would
be over. So mostly he was alone, and the routine
rhythm of his daily life
was unbroken. It is little wonder then that he
screamed when he awoke one
morning to find a strange animal sleeping next to him
in his hut.
Though it looked
and smelled like a wild beast, it was, he saw as he
edged toward the door
post where his spade stood, dressed in some crazy kind
of clothing. He
thought it was a giant monkey at first, with its long
almost straight head
hair that bushed out as it fell and the beard, greasy
and brilliant black
with streaks of desert dust and little balls of
crusted mud, and its shining
black face, like tanned black goat leather. Its hair
was too dirty then
for him to notice that it was really of two colors,
with thin rays of light
yellow emerging as it spread outward to his shoulders.
The strange being
was taller than he, he thought, with thin and curling
black hair on its
chest beneath the open tunic, and on legs and arms. It
wore a tunic of
thin-woven grass and a skirt of wider woven grass to
its knees. Both looked
too stiff to be comfortable, and were frayed and
holey, hardly covering
the body, though Ram remained unsure whether the
apparition were male or
female. It looked as if it were bigger than he, but it
was emaciated and
hungry looking, lips drawn back from glowing white
teeth and gray gums
in its sleep, before his scream opened its black eyes,
the whites a little
yellow behind their bloodshot, weary and
10. Arm and Ram
From Arm's Chronicle of IS
Ram was the first man I met
in the land of
the Marsh River. He came close to killing me before we
could talk together,
for Marshtown is a place of strange fears, and so he
began to teach me
about the strangeness of the place to which IS had
I found Ram after the sun
had set, sitting
on a mat on the floor of his hut, leaning against the
wall, with his chin
upon his chest, such a strange being! Beside him was a
box and a small,
clear bottle I could see through, on its side with a
little brown water
in it. The man himself looked like you and me in most
ways, but his skin,
hair, and clothing were much different from ours.
His skin was the color of
dried grass, like
our kilts when they are new. And there was so much
skin, so little hair,
a little brown hair on his head and chin, but almost
none on his arms or
his legs below the knees. I could see little else of
his body, for he wore
a kilt tightly woven of tiny threads and with separate
legs. Did you know
that I brought the idea of pantaloons from Marsh
River? And he wore a kind
of jacket that covered his body between his neck and
his waist, held together
in front with tiny buttons made of bones. His feet
were covered with what
I later learned was the skin of another animal. His
nose towered out of
his face, like a stone on a hillside, and he snorted
in his sleep.
Despite my amazement,
curiosity, and growing
hunger, I lay down and dozed off, feeling safe now. At
dawn, I awakened,
having heard a kind of shout. I was resting on my
back. Above me stood
the man, the look of terror in his almost white eyes.
He spoke words I
did not understand then, but I knew he feared me. He
moved toward his door
and took up a sharp edged tool like a shovel. So, I
did not move, but only
looked quietly up at him and spoke.
"I am Arm of the swamp. I
have crossed the
dry lands to speak with you about the drying up of the
To his terror was added
he did not believe in my reality. Never taking his
eyes from me, he backed
out the door, so he stood with the rose of dawn on the
right side of his
body and seemed to glow a little in his white
clothing, like a silver bird
in the swamp. Then he spoke more words.
I began to fear that I would
be unable, after
my long journey, to do what I had come for. Perhaps I
might place the waterroot
in a good place, not here, but where this water came
from, so that IS would
have a presence here. But I would not be able to talk
with these men, to
explain to them what IS sang to me about the end of
the water and the death
of the swamp.
I turned on my side and sat
up very slowly.
The man looked as if he might run away from the hut,
but he did not. He
only watched me with great care. I looked into his
eyes as kindly as I
could and spoke again.
"How can I speak to you,
stranger, that you
may know me?"
He only stared, his mouth a
little open. I
thought of offering him a gift, but what had I? An
empty pail, an empty
basket, and the pail of IS.
I opened my shoulder basket,
thinking of him as a tiny tree frog whom I wanted to
pass without frightening.
I set the pail of IS on a brown-grass mat that covered
soil of the hut and loosened its bindings, then opened
it and pushed it
cautiously toward him. He edged toward it, then peered
into it, then bent
down to look closely -- but always with an eye on me.
What was there to
see? Some murky water with a green mossy grass
floating submerged. When
he stood again and stepped away from the door, the
sunlight shifted to
a yellow glow that irradiated the pail, and a little
of the golden sky
reflected in the water. Then he kneeled down before
it, letting his spade
come to rest, and put his hands around it and shook it
a little, then stopped,
watching the small waves grow still and the soil
settle downward again.
He seemed to grow calm
looking into the pail.
Wondering what he saw there, I moved toward him and we
looked into it together.
Then I felt a song welling up in me.
Our parent's water rises and
falls; it rises
The grasses and trees drink it in;
We eat sun fruit and waterroot.
We eat frog nuts and starflower
We make water on grasses and trees.
The clouds drop water on bushes and
on bushes and ferns.
The bushes and ferns drink it in;
Our parent's water rises and falls;
So I sang the old song, but
as I came to the
place of beginning again, I felt and then heard
strange sounds leaving
my tongue, giving it shapes it had not known before,
though those shapes
were familiar. I was singing the same song, the old
song of our lives,
but in words I had never spoken before.
When I had finished, the
stranger took the
last drink from his bottle. Then he said to me, "And
you can speak our
lingo, too. By Carlo, you's human, you are, though I'd
never have believed
to see a monkey so big and talking too."
So I found that I could talk
with this man.
Among the songs of IS, sung to me at the secret pool,
was the song of the
words these people use in the land of Marsh River.
Though I had never used
them, I had them, and slowly I did use them, though
many I heard had no
meaning to me; "human" and "monkey" did not then.
This man was a keeper of
water gates. In his
box was a drawing with language upon it such as we did
not have then. The
drawing was a map. It showed a large lake behind a
dam. You have made such
things my children, playing in the warm rain. But this
dam was gigantic,
five or six times higher than I stand, made of earth,
and wide enough on
top for twenty or more of us to walk across holding
hands, side by side.
Out of the middle of the dam came a stream called
Marsh River. The stream
spilled from the lake over a stone trough, when there
was enough water,
and fed a small lake at the base of the hills. From
the two ends of the
dam ran large ditches paved with stones. This is how
Ram, my first northern
friend, explained the map to me. These stone ditches
ran out of the hills
and far across the flat land, bringing water to the
waste land and making
it bloom in rich fields. These people take the seeds
of plants, not as
we do, to places near our huts to let them grow near
us, but into large
flat fields, spread out, planted by hundreds of hands.
There were also
such fields in the hills, smaller, but watered by rain
and streams from
the distant mountains.
All of these fields were
southwest of his irrigation
ditch. To the Northeast was a low and forbidding
waste, though beyond it
I could see green hills, and a valley with perhaps
some water before it.
The water on his map was old Marsh Lake, a small pond
at the end of Marsh
River. The waste land, he told me, was once a marsh.
His father had told
him of finding food there, of killing birds and fish
from it, of gathering
sweet fruit there, though it was dangerous and boggy.
Then it came out
nearly as far as his main ditch, but now there was
only the pond, a dirty
and almost lifeless place that no one visited.
There was the dam, he said,
pointing to it
on the map. The dam stopped the water to make the new
Marsh Lake. The water
from the reservoir was directed out though the
aqueducts onto the flat
lands where it watered these fields. As they watered
more fields, less
and less water went over the spillway. Marsh River
dwindled to a creek,
and the marsh dried up into a small dirty pond, old
Marsh Lake. This was
all to the good, said Ram, for it meant much food to
trade up river, and
much wealth and happiness at the end of Marsh River
valley. It meant he
had a peaceful job, opening, closing, inspecting, and
repairing the gates
of the aqueduct, and watching the plants grow.
"But you take too much
water," I said. For
I saw immediately the cause of the silence from the
North. The marsh was
once a very small swamp, with waterroot in it, and
water came down the
Marsh River, passed into this swamp, then travelled
beneath the ground
to our swamp. In this way, IS was once larger, and in
this way is our swamp
fed, though there may be other sources of water coming
to us under the
earth. And we have rain too, but not enough to sustain
our swamp in the
length of time.
Ram replied, "How can we
take too much water?
We do not take more than there is. And you must stop
to look at these beautiful
fields when all the plants grow tall and green, our
wheat, and corn, and
cotton, and flax. This flat land is rich."
Ram said that in the old
tales this dry land
was once a great sea or perhaps a lake that drained
away. Perhaps Carlo,
the maker, was thirsty and drank it up. To bring fresh
water here was to
grow great crops, and because the land was flat and
easy to work and water,
the few men who lived at the mouth of Marsh River,
several thousand of
them, could grow themselves much more than they
needed. By trading the
excess, they brought wealth and comfort to this lonely
valley so distant
from the great cities.
"But if my swamp dies as
this marsh has died,
then the world will die."
Ram replied, "You are a
stranger here, and
though you look funny, I like your looks. But see here
now. You can't go
into Marshtown and say to the high council that this
water is yours. They
can all see that the river ends here. We have traded a
for rich bearing fields. The water was wasted, and now
it is used."
I saw I was making him
angry, and so I said
to him, "And your work that you value, the care of
these ditches -- that
might also be lost if you gave up the water. I see,
new friend, how this
will be hard."
"Yes, mighty hard."
"But would you think
differently if you knew
that many like me will die if you do not share the
"I might. But you are
strange to us, a strange
monkey beast though you talk our lingo. And I see only
one of you with
a tale of crossing the dry lands where there is no
life. I still think
I may be dreaming you."
I replied with joy. "May it
be true that you
are dreaming me, for the songs of dreams are the
truest songs. They are
the songs of IS flowing in your soul."
"Dreams is dreams, fancies.
You don't know
that? I have a mad sister in Marshtown who tells her
dreams to all who
will listen. She says marvelous crazy things. One day
she ran into the
street just at light, still wearing her bed clothes,
and shouting about
the stars had sung her a song. `Oh,' she said, `If
only I could sing that
song to you!' And everyone who was already awake
laughed while those who
were sleeping yet cursed her by Carlo. Some said to
her, 'And did the moon
tell you how he spilled beer on his head?' She just
kept wandering up and
down the streets with her silly smile, babbling that
the stars had sung
her a beautiful song.
"We have seen the moon, a
tiny barren rock
that blinks on and off as the sun chooses to shine
upon it. We have seen
that the stars are other suns, just distant fires
burning in the great
emptiness, the dunes of blowing nothing. How could
Ram sat silently a moment, a
on his lips. I realized that his moon must be our
winking star. He spoke
"People won't believe you're
real, you know.
Some, I think, will want to be rid of you, so they
won't have to believe
I saw then that my task
would be hard among
a people who do not hear their dreams. Not knowing
what is, they would
believe that I was not.
I was lucky to meet this
man, Ram, first in
the valley, for he was wiser and kinder than most.
Others would have taken
my life or my freedom without listening to me and
without teaching me as
he did during our day together, walking among the
growing fields and the
From him, I learned that I
must not just walk
into the Marsh Village below the dam or Marshtown,
east of the reservoir,
and announce myself as I had done with him. Instead, I
must learn how to
approach these places, how to come to them in a way
that would grant me
Ram's goodness can be seen
in his willingness
to help me on my way even though my success might harm
him. He sent me
to an old man who lived on old Marsh Lake, by himself
in a hut. He was
called Marshrat, and was considered a harmless madman
in town and village,
because he lived by himself in the old marsh, doing
nothing and singing
11. The Lonely God
From Scriptures of the Church of Carlo
The myth of the lonely god
is the creation
story of the Church of Carlo in the lower Marsh River
region, though its
origin, like many such tales, is clearly in the
foothills and mountains
near River Falls from which our people spread outward.
The Church of Carlo
is the oldest of the local religions. Traditionally,
the story is told
communally. A teller speaks to the congregation, and
at appropriate points
the congregation responds with the words of Carlo,
"This is better."
Carlo walked the waste land.
The waste land
was a land of rocks. Everything that was was rock,
from the barren mountains,
snowless and black that arose in the northwest to the
sand dunes, of the
tiniest rocks, that slithered across the desert of the
and dry, the waste was not comfortable, and so Carlo
began to feel a longing
for a pleasant place.
As Carlo was wondering what
it was that he
wanted, fire erupted from the rock. A black mountain
split. Molten stone
was cast into the sand-colored sky. A fine gray ash
filled the air and
irritated Carlo's eyes. He began to weep.
As Carlo wept, he began to
realize that his
tears came not merely from the ash hurting his eyes,
but also from his
sorrow. He realized he was alone.
Wondering what was the
answer to loneliness,
Carlo noticed that his tears were changing more things
than his soul. They
fell like rain upon the desert. Soon steam rose into
clouds that cleansed
the sky, changing it from dirty yellow to misty blue.
And when the clouds
became dirty themselves, they rained again.
Carlo thought to himself,
"This is better."
And when Carlo thought the first words of all time, he
felt better too.
For a long time Carlo
enjoyed the changing
of the waste land. He saw snow cover the mountains and
rivers flow down
them, forming lakes and springs among the hills, and
sinking into the dunes
of the far south. He watched the steam rise to clean
the blue sky and fall
in rain to make the land beautiful and various. Wonder
of wonders, he discovered
stars, a great one that warmed the day and many tiny
ones that relieved
the night of darkness.
But there came a day when
Carlo realized that
the loneliness that had awakened in him when he wept
and that had abated
when he spoke to himself, had deepened without his
noticing. Having found
an inward self when he spoke, he now found that place
to be a new waste
land, dark and empty as a well of nothingness. This
darkness gnawed outward,
until he felt he was a mere skin between the beautiful
world and the nothing
To answer this, Carlo threw
words into the
void. He talked to himself:
This knife that carves my guts
This gulf where I can toss no stone;
This well where no water bubbles upward;
This starless sky within,
black as the mountain beneath the snow;
I am falling into myself, and I see no
As long as Carlo talked to himself, it was as if he
of sand from the dunes and threw them one by one into
a deep canyon.
But then a great storm broke
forth over the
land. Lightning cut across the sky and thunder echoed
among the mountains.
The earth shook. Snow slid down the mountains. The air
was filled with
sound, and this opened Carlo's ears. Then he opened
his mouth and shouted
with the elements, his voice echoing for the first
time in all of time.
Talking to the world, Carlo
felt the emptiness
within recede just a little, as on the earliest day of
spring one feels,
though he cannot see, the ice begin to weaken, the
snow begin to shrink.
So, Carlo shouted with the thunder and spat with the
lightning and stomped
with the earthquake and hissed with the rain and the
blowing snow. This
time he said aloud for all to hear:
"This is better."
But it was not good enough.
Though his emptiness
stopped growing, it did not go away. Instead it
remained a vast hollow
in himself as great as all the hollow he could see in
the night sky, but
without a speck of starry light. When he realized
this, Carlo asked the
first question of all time: "Why is there not
something to talk to me?"
For though he spoke with all the sounds of the earth,
they did not reply,
but only went on their ways.
Then Carlo found that his
question spoken aloud
to the clouds and the mountains must have an answer.
When he said "Something!"
and his echoed voice returned, there stood a great
tree, the first peach
tree of all time. Each time he said "Something!"
something would appear:
the first blade of grass, the first strawberry plant,
the first stalk of
wheat, the first waterlily.
When he had talked to the
world a long time,
all the plants that are in the world today were
gathered around him, each
in its place. Oh then how the world talked to him! For
these were the first
living things, and they spoke richly in growing and
dying with the seasons.
Again Carlo said,
"This is better."
Again this was not enough, for
loneliness was much relieved by his conversation with
the plants, they
did not speak to him quite as he seemed to need. Upon
the loneliness within,
the colors, textures, smells and subtle sounds of the
plants made a nest,
covering the outer edge of blackness over with beauty
and ease, but further
in was still the vast void. In a moment of silence in
the dark of the night,
it would threaten to overwhelm him again.
Carlo thought, "While I have
the land and the
plants to talk with, there is no one here who talks to
me. I need someone
to talk to me." And when he said "someone," someone
appeared. He was the
mouse, the first animal that was in all of time. The
mouse sat up and waved
its little feet and squeaked in a tiny voice that just
ear. What the mouse said was this: "I have a hole
inside me that grows
larger and larger until I think I will become nothing
but a hole. I need
someone!" Now Carlo knew just how the mouse felt, and
so he was not surprised
when another mouse appeared when his new companion
said "Someone!" And
each time another mouse appeared, it would stand upon
its hind legs and
make its lonely squeak and there would be another
Now Carlo also knew there
should be many more
companions in the world and so he too said "Someone!"
many times. As he
did so, all the animals that are in the world appeared
one by one, and
each in turn began to repeat his chant until there
were many of each kind.
Second to appear was the cat, and in good time too.
After came all the
fishes and birds, the bees and grasshoppers, the goats
and cows, the great
lion of the mountains, the tiny lizard of the stones,
the lithe snake of
the marsh, the monkey of the forest, and all the
animals that are.
Now Carlo's world was very
full, and there
was much talking in it. The nest he had built in his
inner void was populated
with chattering multitudes. Once again, Carlo said
"This is better," and
once again it was not enough. The noisy myriads talked
they said only a few things: "Hungry! . . . Food Here!
. . . Someone! .
. . Fear! . . . Comfort! . . . Someone!"
Then at last Carlo knew what
he needed, though
he could never have known until his world was full of
Even in that sound remained an emptiness that stood
for the great emptiness
in his soul. He said to himself, "Here I have dreamed
a beautiful and comfortable
place with many to talk to and many to talk to me. But
I have never said
the word the mouse said after I called to him. I need
someone like myself
with whom to share the world. I need another!"
And when he said "Another!"
a man appeared.
So he said "Another!" again quickly, several times,
and in turn a woman
appeared and then another man and then another woman.
This puzzled Carlo
greatly, for this is not how making had happened
before. It seemed there
were only two kinds like him, man and woman. He could
not think long about
this, however, for soon all were talking to each
other, and what they said
was this: "While this is a beautiful world, full of
beauty and song, I
am so lonely! There is inside me an emptiness that
nothing I see can remedy."
But then, quite by accident
two people touched
each other, a man and a woman. When they touched, they
felt better. When
they embraced, they felt better still, and grew quiet.
So it was that all
the people Carlo had called touched, grew quiet, and
settled down to live
together in the world, having found in each other the
answer to their loneliness.
You may think it sad that
Carlo found no other
just for himself. But you should not be sad, for Carlo
found exactly what
it was he had always wanted. Whenever one man or woman
to another, Carlo knows himself as the very opposite
of the empty and the
lonely, and he says to himself and to all of us
"This is better."
12. Marshrat, Son of Marshrat
From Marshrat's Journey
The sunbird had lovely
feathers, golden, flecked
with brown on her breast, but brown flecked with gold
at her throat. Her
folded wing feathers, where he smoothed them down with
a trembling finger,
were pied multicolors, reds and browns and golds and
whites. Her black
eye was circled with black skin, with a rust ray
slanting back, and open
now forever. She lay in Heron's hand, the same hand
that had thrown the
smooth and round black stone, the stone that had
caught the sunbird in
the center of her breast, tumbling her backward from a
fallen branch and
onto the sand at the edge of Marsh Lake, where she
shuddered as he watched
her die. The tears would not come, though at the back
of his throat bitter
weeping crouched. Heron was ten years old. He was
learning that he could
take life, but he could not give it back.
Moments before, he had been
filled with excitement,
hiding behind a clump of palmetto, fingering the
carefully selected collection
of stones in his pocket. He had cultivated his skill
to impress the village
boys. He could set up leaves, even from fruit trees,
against a sandbank
and pierce them, even at twenty paces. The sunbird sat
on the deadwood.
She would lift her head at regular intervals and sing
through her melody.
If he timed his movements right, he could send the
stone through the palmetto
leaves, catching her in the midst of trilling, and she
would never see
what hit her. To bring down this target was a
challenge, and the difficulty
of it lured him.
Now that difficulty was
passed, and another
was before him. "I didn't mean for you to die," he
muttered. "I only wanted
to see if I could do it." But Heron was not really
capable of lying to
himself. Something in him wanted to have power, not
merely the power of
casting a stone accurately, but the power of life and
death over another.
Perhaps this was because the village boys bullied him,
ridiculing and combining
against the loner with an eccentric father and no
mother. Though he was
very young at ten, still Heron understood at least
dimly that the anger
in the stone that killed the sunbird was really aimed
at those boys.
Blindly, still unable to
shed tears, Heron
wished. He wished with all his being, body and soul,
for the life of the
sunbird. "Don't let her die! Oh, Carlo speak her into
life again!" His
being was centered for that time on finding any way at
all of evading responsibility
for his act, an act that he felt to be murder. Heron
had eaten the bobwhites
and gobblers his father, Water Reed killed for their
table. On his feet
were leather shoes, made from a neighbor's elderly
goat with whom Heron
had a personal relationship only a year ago. He knew
these things too,
but still felt something deeply wrong in having slain
The short beach was sandy.
He could look from
here out over the small Marsh Lake. This was in the
days before this lake
became Old Marsh Lake, when the marsh was alive.
Though Marsh River had
been dammed and the new Marshtown was growing on the
new Marsh Lake, irrigating
the waste around the marsh was only a dream. Heron
could see most of the
shore of the lake from this spot. Surrounding the lake
was forest and water
meadows, and directly across in the bright sun, he
could see the curved-neck
shapes of silver egrets, and his sharp eyes could even
see the vague movements
of a darker heron or two in the shadows of the shore
trees. Where he stood
was near the path between his father's little farm and
the village, making
it a favorite play spot for local children. Were he to
stay here long,
someone would come. Were boys from the village to
arrive, he would have
to show them his kill with pride, to boast of this
deed that had shamed
him so completely. He couldn't bear that, and so he
was quick to break
off a broad leaf in which to wrap the sunbird, and
then to disappear with
his burden and his stick down a narrower private path
that would bring
him to his own place in the marsh.
The wet land around the lake
could be dangerous
to those who did not know it well. There was ground
that was mud beneath
a seemingly solid crust, where one could sink to the
waist and perhaps
never get out. There were stories of deeper mudholes
and of quicksand,
where one would be sucked out of sight. People of the
the marsh dangerous, telling such tales to keep their
children away from
it, and then believing them without knowledge of their
truth. Water Reed,
however, loved the marsh and all that lived there,
even the tiny foam-mouthed
snake. It was smaller than a garden snake, a uniform
brown, but when it
opened its mouth to strike with envenomed fangs, it
appeared to have been
scooping storm foam from the lakeside. Heron had seen
this one truly dangerous
denizen, though it was shy and rare, and so for this
and to test surfaces,
he always carried a stick when he walked into the
Heron's private place was a
hummock deep in
the marsh. It was like a small island, and when the
water was high in the
rainy season, he would have to remove his shoes and
wade part of the way
to it through knee-deep water, carefully keeping to
his narrow path of
solid ground. The island was shaped like a crescent
moon, with an inlet
on the southern side that was like a small pond in the
rainy season and
was connected to the lake. The inlet became a pool in
from the rest of the lake by a stretch of reed and
grass filled mud. Along
this shore, there was a meadow, where short grass made
a pleasant lounging
place in the cooler days of early spring. This was
Heron's thinking place,
where he nursed the bruises to body and to spirit
inflicted by the village
boys and the other sufferings of childhood, where he
dreamed of revenge
and, alternatively, of how generously he would use
power over his tormentors
should he ever gain it. If he sat quietly in the
grass, or further back
in the shade of a live oak, he could watch the small
animals of the marsh
emerge to sun themselves: turtles and frogs would
climb onto drift logs
and lift their heads toward the sky. Some days the
frogs would sing. A
hawk would circle the island and as its shadow passed
over, there would
be twenty plops and splashes. When the water was
smooth again, three pointed
turtle heads and the double bubbles of frog eyes would
poke above the water,
watching for more shadows.
Heron brought the sunbird to
this place for
burial. He hoped when he opened the folded leaf that
she would fly up and
consecrate his place with her song and the grace of
her flight, but her
dead eye still accused him from a head bent
unnaturally to the side, her
beak open now in an attitude that suggested suffering.
With his stick, he dug in a
bare spot of ground
in the shade of the tallest central oak facing his
clearing. When he had
buried her, cradled in her leaf coffin, he took from
his pocket the six
remaining throwing stones and pressed them into the
earth above her grave,
making a triangular pattern. When she was buried, she
was finally dead.
There was no bringing her back. He had killed her.
Silently his tears fell
at last onto the dirty hands -- his hands -- that lay
open on his lap as
he rested in the silent shade.
A few days later, Heron
returned to the sunbird's
grave with a folded paper in his pocket. On the paper
were these words.
A sunbird was sent to me.
I sent her away--
Not on her wings that reflect the after
Not on her song that draws my heart into
I sent her away with a stone heart
Into the dark ground,
Sunbird that was sent to me.
It was signed at the bottom with his name. He lifted
the six stones,
scooped a shallow depression in which he placed the
folded paper, covered
it over again, and replaced the black stones in their
Then thirty years passed.
"If the councilors would
come to the marsh,
I could show them its beauty fading. The water level
is lower. Fewer fish
can live in the silty water. There is less food for
the water birds, and
so they do not hatch many eggs, and each year fewer
return. The hummocks
become so dry in summer that the plants on the highest
parts dry up into
dust, and a few of the trees have begun to die
prematurely as well, so
that islands are brown centers with green fringes as
you can see well by
looking down from the hills." Water Reed was speaking
before the council
in Marshtown. This was in the days after the dam was
built, when the new
meeting hall was not yet built, and the council would
gather in Marshtown
at each of the four annual festivals, meeting in a
tent set up on the common
for this purpose. The tent gave shelter from the sun,
but was open all
around, for in those days, the council really
consisted of all the citizens
who came to the meetings. Usually, they would talk
about what needed to
be done until they agreed on it, but sometimes, when
not be ended, they would vote.
The reaction to Water Reed's
plea was mixed.
There were many in the town who, though they knew
little of the marsh,
still appreciated its beauty. Part of the spring
festival was to gather
on the shore of old Marsh Lake near Water Reed's fruit
and vegetable farm
for a great outdoor meal during the time of the birds'
return. Then many
birds that visited the marsh only a few days each year
would be singing,
swimming, and soaring: the very air would seem to live
with music and colored
flight. And Water Reed was right. The older citizens
were sure they remembered
festivals of the past as more vibrant and felt that
recently the beauty
and frenzy of that festival day had declined.
Wheatbeard, a man cunning
in having his way, knew how the people would feel, and
so he was ready
"It is the custom of the old
to remember their
youthful days as more full of life, since the old
themselves were more
full of life in their youth. Water Reed grows old now,
and he remembers
the past as better than it was. Our aqueduct has not
really changed the
"It is true that something
is killing a few
of the trees on the larger islands. We can all see the
brown centers from
our southern hills, but this is not extensive or
serious. In a few years,
it will take care of itself.
"We should pay attention,
instead, to what
we can gain from the proposed new aqueduct. Look
around you at how our
town has grown. We are more prosperous. We have more
fine metal tools,
more pleasant homes, a greater variety of foods. All
of this has come from
the riches of our blooming desert. Having converted
waste land into farm
land, we have grains and fibers to trade up the river.
This trade has brought
us good things and has attracted skilled people from
up river into our
"To open a second aqueduct
will only increase
these good things. There may be somewhat fewer birds,
but our spring festival
will continue to be fine enough for us. There may be
fewer fish in the
old lake, but the new lake is rich with fish for our
tables. We really
have nothing to lose and much to gain."
Water Reed responded, "But
you don't know what
you will lose. The marsh has depended for all the time
we know on the flow
of Marsh River. The new plan will stop that flow into
the marsh for much
of the year. That must change the marsh. We may not
know exactly how, though
I believe we can already see the decline in the birds
and trees. The point
is that if the marsh is changed, we cannot be sure of
bringing it back
again if we don't like the change.
"Why don't we let enough be
enough? We have
dammed the river and made a new lake, and this has
made our lives easier.
We irrigate vast fields in the desert, and this makes
our lives more pleasant.
These are good things. Our lives are very good. Why
change? Why not keep
things as they are, having our comfort and having the
marsh. Surely its
beauty is reason enough to keep it."
"Beauty? What is the value
of beauty?" argued
Wheatbeard. "Don't misunderstand me. I love what is
truly beautiful as
much as any man. But I think that true beauty should
also be useful. I
look upon the beauty of the flax and corn that grows
in our desert fields.
That, my friends, is practical beauty, the rich rows
of gold and green,
the honey glow of the ripe corn in the boats that
float from our port during
harvest. I don't object to the beauty of a swamp, with
its sinkholes and
foam snakes, but that seems to me hardly to compare
with our golden harvest
fields and the fine linen of our looms."
"But the marsh has a life! A
life of its own
that is not ours to take!"
"You seem to me a little
selfish, Water Reed.
The whole town benefits from our fields, but only a
few, mainly you, seem
seriously to believe that we should sacrifice those
obvious benefits for
a piece of essentially useless ground." Wheatbeard
then paused, and with
a fixed, calculated smile, looked around at the
gathered citizens of Marshtown,
before he made his final move.
"When we see someone wanting
to hoard something
for himself, we call him a rat. Perhaps, Water Reed,
your true name should
This comment brought a laugh
from the crowd.
To Heron, who had watched his father's defense with
quiet pride, it seemed
that everyone was laughing at his father, as they
always had -- the ridiculous
man who lived next to the swamp, who took time from
valuable work to study
the ways of the birds and other animals there, who had
brought up his son
to look and to act like him. Both had full beards,
though Water Reed's
was white, while Heron's was a rich chestnut brown.
Sure, his stories of
the marsh were interesting to children; they
remembered some of them and
so felt the magic of the silver egret's flight, like a
soaring orchid --
but now they were adults and this was a serious
Not everyone laughed, but
many of those who
were sympathetic to Water Reed's point of view were
silenced by the name
of Marshrat. They did not want to be in the minority
who would be called
marshrats for the rest of their days. To be so
excluded from the community
would be a pain in itself that most of them were
unwilling to bear, and
this exclusion would lead to other separations more
damaging to their families.
Wheatbeard, with this move, had effectively silenced
the minority, and
so the town agreed to build the second aqueduct.
That afternoon as Water Reed
and Heron left
Marshtown, they were accompanied by about a dozen
residents of the lower
village whose way home was the same. Heron noticed
that no one spoke to
them. The others spoke to each other quietly, the four
or five children
lingering behind, talking and snickering among
themselves. Though he was
forty years old, there was still inside him the boy's
hurt and anger at
the bullying of the village boys, and it was this boy
so near his surface
that heard with red, blinding anger the sing-song
taunts the children sent
after the pair as they parted in the village: "There
go Marshrat and Marshrat,
the son of Marshrat!"
Fifteen years later, only
carrion birds came
to the black, dead marsh, and for them the pickings
were lean. A few years
before Water Reed's death, without knowing then what
they saw, Heron and
his father watched the last silver egret to visit the
marsh drift down
to the barren, muddy shore of the tiny pond that was
all that remained
of old Marsh Lake. It stood for a moment, drawing to
it the golden spring
sun and making a spot of brilliance in desolation, not
but seeming to look with bewilderment at a scene that
failed to match the
glory in its memory. Then it took wing, circling
northward in search of
another home. After Water Reed died, no one remembered
Heron's true name,
and so, with both bitterness and pride, he thought of
himself, just as
all of Marsh River did, as Marshrat.
"Remember, Heron, the day I
showed you the
Heron's memory of that
moment was clear as
the stillest pool of the lower Marsh River stream, the
trickle of the river
below the dam. The sun shown hot, seeming almost to
have weight as it pressed
on his bare young shoulders. That was when he was four
years old. The possum
lay partially curled inward on its side in some short
sparse grass, along
a narrow path between the garden and the lakeside. He
didn't know whether
his father had killed it to keep it out of his beans,
but it was very dead.
Its belly was open and maggots squirmed there. Flies
buzzed around it,
and landed on its open eye, and on its reddish tongue
that poked out from
between the pointed little teeth beneath its dry white
snout. His father
had brought him here, silently, in answer to a
"Father, where is my
"She's dead, Heron. I've
told you that before."
"But the kids in town all
have mothers. Their
mothers give them food and hug them and put them to
bed in the night."
"I know that, Heron, and I'm
sorry -- very
sorry -- that your mother died. I would like her to
hug me and put me to
bed in the night, too. But she is gone, and so we have
to take care of
"But why doesn't she come
mother went away up river for a long time, and then
she came back. Why
won't our mother come back?"
Water Reed could not speak.
Heron could not
understand at four the pain that turned Water Reed's
brown/green eyes hard
above his dark, full beard. And Water Reed could not
find any easy answer
that Heron would understand, and so in suffering
blindness he did something
he often regretted thereafter. He took Heron to see
the dead, garden-robbing
possum where it was rotting in the sun.
"See this possum, Heron."
"Yes, Father." Heron looked
very solemn, his
four-year-old face held rigid before the inconceivable
mystery of death.
"I know that, Father."
"Do you know what it means
to be dead?"
"This possum will never get
up and walk again.
It will not come in the night to our garden to find
good things to eat.
It will never go home to its nest to feed its little
ones. When it died,
that was the end of everything that it does. In a few
days you can come
here and see only its bones left here on the ground,
and next year the
bones will be gone, too, turned back into the dust
from which its body
was made. Your mother is dead like this, three years
ago, and by now her
bones too are probably melted into the earth where we
This was hard for Water Reed
to say. He felt
the terrible cruelty of it in his own pain at
remembering her face, its
suffering in giving birth, its joy in nursing and
caressing, its stillness
in death. He wondered, What was he doing to his son?
"It won't go back to its
"Then they will die."
"Their father will take care
"Yes, I remember, Father,
the day you helped
me understand that mother was gone forever. I remember
it very well."
Water Reed, now Marshrat to
all but Heron,
lay on his bed, paralyzed by a stroke. He had wasted
away for a week, with
Heron tending him alone, waiting patiently to die.
Often he slept, but
sometimes he spoke in a slurred speech that only
Heron's love could understand.
"You needn't be sorry,
Father. What you taught
me was good, and I have never forgotten it."
"But it seemed so cruel, as
if I tried to hurt
you with my own pain. I have often regretted it."
"You shouldn't, Father. It
was a good thing
to do, and I am truly glad of it."
"Still, I am sorry!"
Those were Water Reed's last
words to Heron,
who from that day was known only as Marshrat.
13. Question 4
From "The Questions of Raisin and Chick"
in the holy writings of the Cult of Song
Mother, what is the difference between our singing
and that of the wind
in the grass?
In one sense, there is no
difference at all,
for each is part of the song of IS. With IS, all songs
are chords in the
whole, strands of the vast web.
The song of IS is made of
the songs of the
world. Each thing -- the plant, the fish, the rock,
the sheep, the grass,
the bee, the wind, the cloud -- each thing doing what
it naturally does
creates its part of the sound.
14. At the Hearth of Marshrat
Arm's journey across the dry
lands had tested
his body and his will, but in a way, the problems he
had to solve were
simple. Would he go on? Would he give up? The problems
that lay ahead he
began to see as soon as he encountered Ram. In the
desert he was a solitary
soul, struggling through a hostile landscape,
sustained by his mission.
Now he was a solitary soul among a possibly hostile
people, and his mission
was no longer simply to arrive somewhere, but to
persuade. The idea he
had to convey was simple enough: "Please use the water
of Marsh River sparingly,
leaving enough to preserve the lives of my people of
the swamp and of IS,
the very soul of our world, for if IS dies, so does
our world." But Arm
saw already that this simplicity would be easily
apparent only to him.
Everyone else in the Marshtown area would be likely to
think that the water
passed them before draining away into a dead and ugly
marsh and then sinking
away into the waste land. Why should they waste this
water, after discovering
a way to make it serve them and make their lives rich
and secure? Why,
after putting the sweat of their arms into the dam and
the aqueducts and
the canals and ditches, why then should they say that
this labor was for
nothing and let perhaps half their fields go dry? Why
should they do these
things for a few odd looking monsters that claimed to
hold the secret of
the world's life in a distant swamp that was probably
as dead and ugly
as old Marsh Lake?
Arm could see that this was
how things were,
but what could he do about it? He knew no answer, and
so he knew he would
have to find out. To find out, he followed Ram's
advice; he went to Marshrat,
whose hut and garden were near old Marsh Lake.
At Marsh Lake death and loss
This was because though it was water in a waste land,
the water itself
was a waste land.
As Arm walked along a sandy
strip between the
hills and the dry marsh, he looked out over the marsh,
thinking that once
it had been like his swamp. Where there had been
shaded islands, were now
low humps with dead trees stretching sad bones of arms
above thorny bushes.
Stream beds had become dusty trails; pools were now
boggy pits of black
water, surrounded by clumps of dry-looking and dark
plants, like nettles
Walking in the dry lands had
taught him that
different lands teach different ways of living. He
looked at this land
and wondered what way of living it taught. He felt
repelled by it as he
had never felt, even when near death in the dunes.
This waste seemed to
hate itself and all that looked upon it. It seemed to
be wishing itself
Perhaps he was seeing it at the wrong time. If Ram
was right that once
all of this flat land and marsh was a great lake, then
for the face of
the land to change was part of the singing of the
world. Even this dead
swamp must play its part, being one of the ways of the
land. Perhaps over
time, it would teach creatures and plants how to live
in it, and with them
would come singing in which he could join. But on that
day when he first
walked along the dead marsh with a little of Ram's
food in him, he could
find no kinship between himself and that land.
Marsh Lake looked like a
large boggy pit. He
saw nothing living in it. Bleak and jagged plants
clung to its black shore,
and as the day heated up, a stinking steam rose from
it, hurting his nose
and making his eyes cry. On the hills to his left were
grass and trees
that reminded him of the swamp, though many of the
plants were strange
to him. There were fields too, large squares on
hillsides, with rows of
small plants, all the same.
He found Marshrat in his
garden. It was a good
place to find him. As Ram had told him, Marshrat's hut
stood in a grove
of trees on the west bank of the trickle that was what
remained of Marsh
River when it flowed into the lake. It was a small
hut, much like those
in the swamp, made of wooden poles with woven grass
walls, but with a thatched
As he approached it, he saw
Marshrat not far
away, hoeing in his garden. He bent and chopped at the
the plants he did not want there. He saw there were
many kinds of plants
Marshrat wanted to remain.
Marshrat was smaller than
Ram, who was nearly
Arm's size, and he seemed thin as a whistle reed. He
stood only to Arm's
chin, and being an aged man, his back was bent, making
him shorter than
he had once been. On his head and face was white hair,
hanging down onto
his jacket and covering his neck. The skin of his face
was a bright mixture
of tan and red, like the fruit of marshmellon. His
eyes seemed very small,
for they were hidden deep within the wrinkles of his
skin and beneath bushes
of hairs above them.
In fact, when they first
looked upon each other,
Arm wondered if Marshrat had any eyes at all. Marshrat
heard Arm walking
in his garden and turned toward him. Seeing him, he
leaned his head upon
his hoe and studied Arm through dark slits among deep
that, like Ram, Marshrat would find him alien, Arm
stood quietly to let
this familiar stranger study and overcome his fear.
When Marshrat spoke
in a slow and thoughtful manner, as if considering
carefully, it seemed
as if he had never been afraid.
"I think I am seeing a
legend, for you look
to be a black monkey. I've heard tell of such
creatures living beyond the
desert. And you have all the marks of one. But to see
one wandering here!"
Marshrat seemed reluctant to
perhaps he might frighten Arm or make this wondrous
legendary beast disappear.
So only after he looked Arm over quietly for some
time, did Arm speak to
"I am Arm. I have come with
IS from the swamp
beyond the dry lands about the stopping of the water."
Marshrat shifted his weight,
as if ready to
run, upon hearing the first words. He was shocked that
this being spoke,
and in his own tongue. But he quickly controlled
himself, and considered
"Not just a big monkey, now,
are you? I have
also heard tell that the monkeys were another kind of
men, and so you are
if you talk to me, and in my own language. I thought
you would grunt and
beg for a banana, like the monkeys of the south
mountain forests, but no,
you come announcing yourself as an ambassador,
escorting some dignitary,
though I can't see him yet, and you come on serious
"I can see we must talk. I
am not a talker,
for I live here alone, apart from the big bellies in
town. And when I see
them, there is little to say. What answer can you make
to a gulp and a
"And now, today, you come,
making me want to
talk, to ask questions and learn of an unseen world.
But I can see that
first you'll have to tell me what you have to say,
being on quest as you
Then he returned quietly to
weeding his row,
while Arm stood patiently and watched him. In a few
minutes he was done,
and then he turned and spoke to Arm again: "You must
have come far. I am
sure that in your home, there is no mud or dust caked
in your hair, and
that your bones do not show so high in face and ribs,
nor through holes
in your clothing.
"Let's see, what food might
you take? I have
some lettuce here."
He carefully pulled some
leaves from a row
of plants and gave them to Arm. To him they smelled
wonderful, and he ate
them on the spot.
"Aye, you are hungry, I
He gathered more food from
his garden. All
these foods were familiar to Arm, though different
from what he was used
to, for they had been cultivated with care, and were
generally larger and
sweeter than the varieties gathered by the children of
the swamp. Then
Marshrat took Arm to a pool in the stream where he
freshened the water
of IS and bathed. In the shade in front of his hut,
they sat before his
cold fire circle, and Arm filled himself for the first
time in many days
with the fruits of Marshrat's garden and trees.
And being full, he slept,
though it was not
Next morning they spoke of
IS. And as they
spoke, Arm began to see how well he was guided in
coming first to Ram who
was kind and selfless and then to Marshrat who was so
learned and wise.
Marshrat understood the
quest nearly as well
as Arm did even before it was explained.
"I expect you have come
about the drying of
the marsh and the end of the flowing of Marsh River.
You could come only
across the dry lands because we men know all the lands
up the river, but
almost never go into the dry lands, there being
nothing there for us. Of
course, long ago, before my time, in my grandfather's
time I think, there
was a crazy man, called Sandrat, (so you see how I
come by my name), who
claimed he was called to explore the desert.
"He packed up food and water
and walked into
the dunes. One day, he returned half dead and crazier
than ever. So the
story goes. The story includes you. He said he came to
a swamp that sang
and where the black monkey people lived. He said he
sang with the swamp
and talked with the monkeys and learned the meaning of
"And now, here you are, come
from the dunes,
a black monkey to talk with another crazy man. And
instead of talking,
you are listening to me! Tell me about yourself!"
So, Arm told his story: how
IS had sung to
him, and how he had brought a part of IS across the
land of the pricklies,
the land of the stones, and the land of the dunes.
"Now that will be a
problem," Marshrat said.
"You must place this waterroot in a safe and still
place where it can grow
and from where it can send its messages down stream to
the swamp. I wonder
how long such information will take to travel?
Probably quite long now,
for the flow quickly grows less. As summer heats, the
water rats will take
more, until none at all flows from the reservoir into
Marsh Lake. It will
be after harvest, well into cool season before the
again, and then it will be slow, for many people along
the river use its
"Why do you call these men
water rats? What
is this rat that you are Marshrat, and once there was
"Ah, rats now, is it? Well
you see we have
in the hills a small, brown animal that could sit on
your hand, who is
known, perhaps unjustly, as a hoarder. It is said that
in his underground
burrows he takes and stores anything that will fit,
spending his whole
life enlarging the hole and carrying moveable objects
that interest him
Arm understood. "There was
among us children
of the swamp, not long ago, one who became ill. For a
time, she slept much.
When she slept she had dark dreams in which she
talked. And when she was
awake, she gathered sun fruit that was then in season,
piling it in her
corner of her hut. She would share it with no one,
neither would she eat
it, and so it rotted there and flies ate it."
"Yes, to be a rat as we say
it is to have that
sort of sickness. So I am said to hoard the marsh,
though you see I am
not very successful. And Sandrat wanted the dunes for
himself. At least
that's what people thought."
"You do not seem sick to
"Nor to myself. I think it
is the big bellies,
the water rats who are sick, for they hoard the water
and starve the marsh.
Now you tell me their hoarding does far more harm than
to my marsh, that
it threatens the world."
"Yes, I think that is true.
If the men of Marsh
River take all of its water, then the swamp will begin
to die. When IS
sang to me, it said this northern source was one of
only two sources of
"That makes your quest a
hard one, my friend.
And the first step, I think, must be to place your
waterroot in the best
"We cannot put it in Marsh
Lake, for nothing
lives there now but foul and poisonous plants. We must
find a pool in the
stream that is protected from prying eyes, that will
not dry up in summer,
and through which some water will flow until the water
stops in summer.
We must do this today, now, before talking more, so
that IS may understand
as soon as possible whatever it can understand about
this northern silence."
In the early morning light
they walked out
together along the stream of Marsh River, searching
for such a pool. They
found one not so far from Marshrat's hut, though they
looked much of the
morning before choosing that one as best. It was much
like the pool of
IS in the swamp, which is why Arm favored it.
In this part of the river,
it had divided into
several streams that flowed into the lake. All of
these but two were now
dry, the two deepest remaining. And in one, there was
a place where the
water ran narrow and deep, as deep as Arm's knees,
though he could easily
step across it. The other branch, not far away was
wide and shallow with
a sandy bottom. Marshrat said it would be dry sand in
a moon, but the narrow
stream would flow until midsummer, and then the pools
would stand, especially
those in the shade.
The pool they chose was well
shaded, with a
narrow grassy bank where it was pleasant to sit. And
there were gold carp
resting in it. After their tramp along the stream,
they were tired. So
after emptying the long carried pail into this quiet
pool that stood outside
the main current, they sat on the bank, and Marshrat
talked about these
men Arm would have to deal with, the men he called big
bellies and water
The dam and the aqueducts
were begun in the
time of Marshrat's grandfather. The people who had
come down along the
river to settle here wanted water for their fields,
and it was far to carry
the water up to them on the backs of donkeys or in
pails on their shoulders.
In the dry season of summer, only shaded and watered
gardens could be made
to grow. The people could grow some grain and some
grass, but very little
without carrying water.
They gathered together as
was their practice
when troubled and had the idea of the reservoir. This
would make a larger
shore where grass for grazing would grow. It would be
easier to carry water
from the large and higher lake, and in the dry season
there would be plenty
They built this dam during
the childhood of
Marshrat's grandfather, and by the time of Marshrat's
father, the east
aqueduct was also built, and the people began to farm
the flat land to
the east of the marsh.
Before the building of the
aqueduct, the flow
of water over the dam seemed to stay as it was before
the dam was built.
But after the aqueduct, the marsh started to shrink,
and when the second
aqueduct took water to the new fields west of the
marsh, old Marsh Lake
began to die.
As the flat land fields of
corn and vegetables
grew green in dry summer, the swamp grew gray and
black around its edges
and in high places, shrinking into stinking mud where
poisonous and prickly
plants sprang up.
"In the second summer of the
the last silver egret flew north, never to return.
Wild ducks and geese
ceased to nest in spring and fall, and the great
cloudy crane, sang a farewell
song." Marshrat's voice became itself a farewell song,
the song of thank
you, as he spoke of these, his friends. He had known
these birds, birds
known still in the swamp, for they pass through there
as well in their
seasons. He had listened to their songs and had sung
with them. It was
as he spoke of these birds and of singing with them,
that Arm felt again
the death of Sand and his night of despair in the
dunes, but there was
a deeper pain here.
Though Arm had known quiet
in the desert and
suffered from it, now he felt how the dry land stood
between him and home
and between him and the songs of the children of the
swamp. In Marshrat's
echo of a farewell, he heard the singing of the
children around the fire.
With tears in his eyes, as
the sky began to
glow red and gold, reflected from behind western
clouds, he turned to Marshrat,
who sat in a dark shadow beneath an old willow,
looking into the pool,
his arms wrapped about his knees, his white beard
resting on his knees.
"It is too quiet here. Your
lament is like
the farewell song of the children."
"Yes, I feel in me that
there is something
that belongs with my thoughts, some words and music
perhaps. You see, I
am thought crazy in part because I make songs out here
in my hut and write
them down, though only children are much interested in
hearing them. Sing
me your farewell song."
Thank you companion for
singing among us.
Your song is with us.
You are singing our song.
Though your face glows not in the
Though your voice enters not our
Though your hand strikes not the
Though your ears hear us not,
Still we hear you;
Still our hearts hear you.
You are singing our song.
Your song is with us.
Thank you companion for singing
To sing this song again was
to think of the
singing star and Sand, dry like a leaf in his hand. As
the tears dried
in his eyes, Arm saw how they came to Marshrat's.
"It's a true song, Arm. At
least it should
be true. But it hurts me deep in my heart. It seems to
me, you see, that
the songs of the marsh birds I heard as a boy were my
songs, too. But now
I never hear them. And I never will again. Their songs
are no longer with
me, only the remembrance of having heard them and
thought them beautiful,
having thought that without words they sang the
meanings of my soul. Now,
without those songs, I think my soul must be empty."
When Arm saw on his face
such a forlorn look
and heard in his voice such a lonely song, he thought
perhaps he had a
song of comfort and farewell of his own, and so asked
him to sing his song.
Then Marshrat recited a song without music, which was
something new to
Silver, blazing like the
knife edge of a storm
The memory of such silver slices at
When the sun behind a cloud reaches around to pierce
Then I lament you, silver egret.
Your cry entered my breast
Your silver wing cut off my breath
Your eye looked through my eye,
So I saw the marsh with your eye,
The sun glinting from its many
Without your cry, your wing,
My cry is stopped, my words cannot reach, my eye is
Even my song is silence.
This song brought tears to
Arm's eyes, not
of homesickness, but of sorrow and pity, for Arm felt
kinship and pain
in this song.
"My friend," he said, "How
can you make such
a sad song? This is a song not of thank you and
farewell, but of farewell
forever. This is a song of the end of the world! Even
when I felt such
feelings, when I thought I would die in the dunes, I
did not dream of making
such a song."
"This song of mine is the
truth as I see it.
I sing of what is in my heart."
"Yes, I see that we often
feel things we know
not to be true of IS, though they are true for the
moment in our hearts.
Such things can be said, but we cannot sing them. What
I marvel at is that
you can sing what is not."
They talked of singing as
dusk and then darkness
fell on their quiet and sheltered bank before the new
pool of IS.
Marshrat told him that in
the hills no one
sang songs such as Arm had sung him. There were songs
sung in places of
eating and drinking about eating and drinking. There
were better songs
sung about work while working in field and mill. The
best were the festival
songs and some songs of a few women in the back
country, when people sang
of their gratitude and joy in having enough and not
having to fear hunger
in the cool season or dry. But there were no
gatherings around fires where
people sang themselves and their world. No one
remembered such singing.
Marshrat made such songs,
though they were
songs of a self bereft in a world drained of music.
These songs were not
only terrible even in their beauty, but terrifying as
well. To make beauty
of despair stirs the soul, for beneath it and behind
it, pushing it forward
into words is such a longing. But this longing, this
hunger is sure there
is no food for it, and so it is terrifying. Such
emptiness denies, makes
invisible, what Arm saw about himself in every moment
of his togetherness
with life and its creatures. All the singing of the
children of the swamp
grows out of such togetherness. The singing itself
happens in a union and
expresses that union. For him, even to sing alone in
the dry land is to
bring himself into a memory of that union. Their
togetherness is the togetherness
of the world they sing, the union of IS. Their singing
is a part of Singing,
and it is the singing itself that makes this true.
Marshrat sang alone. And in
he made the songs of the lone singer, in the empty
hut, in the dead world,
among silent stars, cold and terrible.
Though Arm had made a friend
and found an ally,
it became clearer yet on that night what a hard and
dark way he had yet
to go. He had crossed the dry land and come to the dry
people. He had found
on the edge of their land, Marshrat. Marshrat was not
like them, but like
Arm, except that his songs were his own alone, and so
he lived in despair.
They, the water rats and big bellies, had no songs at
all. They were without
ears and eyes. Though they drank in all the water,
their bodies and souls
were as dry as Sand's when he died in the dunes. How
could he talk to them?
How could he sing to them?
15. Who Sings in His Dream
From scriptures of the New Church of Marsh River
and later of the Cult of Marshrat the Martyr
Now my children I ask you to
You will quickly see that this is not so easy as some
might think. When
there is nothing, there is neither any object in the
world, like this apple
I hold in my hand, nor any hand to hold the apple, nor
any room in which
to behold the apple, nor any world on which the room
may rest, nor any
blue sunny sky in which the planet may swim, nor --
and this is most important
-- nor is there any you to look upon the nothing that
For a child to truly imagine
nothing, it is
best perhaps to think of sleep. You close your eyes in
darkness and open
them in light. You know from those nights when
wakefulness is insistent,
that the hours from dark to dawn are long indeed, but
when you sleep dreamlessly,
it is as if there were nothing between sleeping and
waking. Then there
is no world and no awareness of the world. Then there
is no time nor space,
nor any of the ways by which we know and portion out
This is how it was in the
nothing before time.
Though there are many
legends that tell of
the creation, none of these myths is true, for each
talks of the universe
as always being here. These are the products of the
ignorant. It is a wise
child who asks, then, how is it that now there is
something? If once there
was nothing, how did something come of it, for surely
I see the apple,
in the hand, in the room, on the world, in the lighted
There is only one story,
told from the beginning
by our fathers, and written in the Sacred Texts of the
Martyr. We know
this is the one true story because it tells us how the
universe came to
be, even though before there was nothing at all. This
story came to our
first father in a dream, spoken in his mind by IS
himself, the very Being
Before there was anything
the Mind of IS slept,
and in that mind there was nothing at all just as in
your dreamless sleep
nothing dwells. Then a dream came to the Mind of IS, a
dream of boundless
space and the flowing of time.
In his dream, IS fell into
space tumbling aimlessly
in the vastness of emptiness, feeling the soft touch
of time upon his face.
Such a dream would be a nightmare to a human person,
but IS knew his powers,
so then he spoke.
He said "world," and his
feet rested on solid
ground. He said, "light," and sun, moon, and stars
shone upon his world.
He said, "beauty," and all the wonders of the world
appeared: sea and mountain,
cloud and plain. He said, "life," and the world teemed
with living things,
plants and animals, insects and men. He said, "love,"
and all these things
came together in harmony. His eyes were bathed in
colors of flower and
tree, his ears filled with murmurs of breezes in the
pines and grass, his
nostrils with the breath of the ripening corn. He
watched all beings dancing
in his dream, and IS was glad.
And so all things came into
the Mind of IS
as he spoke the words in his dream. And when all the
words that would ever
be spoken were said, they became the words of the
enduring Song of IS,
the song that continues as long as the dream, the song
that sings us into
being and death, waking and sleeping.
In the midst of nothing is
something; in the
midst of sleep is the Dream of IS.
16. The Wakeup Bird
A legend from the Cult of Song
These are the words of the first woman.
"When I first awoke, I heard
the singing of
the wakeup bird. It was singing to me, saying 'Wake
up, woman! Wake up,
woman!' This is how I knew who I was and that I was
"Though I had lived long in
the forest, I had
never been awake before, but in a kind of walking
sleep. But now I sang
back to the bird, and as I sang, I knew I would never
again sleep with
my eyes open.
"So I walked through the
forest seeking another
waking person. I found many walking about their
business, finding food,
or mates, or sleeping by the streams.
"Not until I came out of the
forest and into
the hills did I find another who was awake. We looked
upon each other and
knew that each was awake. I sang my song to him, and
he sang another back
to me. This was the song sung to him by the ground
squirrel: 'Wake up,
man! Wake up, man!'
"Together we built our
house, he making the
walls of sticks and I the roof of grass. There we bore
our children and
taught them the songs of awakening."
17. The High Council of Marshtown
"Keeper of the inner door, I
am Arm, the arm
of IS, ambassador from the swamp beyond the desert,
come to speak to the
High Councilors upon matters of the water."
Marshrat correctly believed
that if Arm depended
upon his strangeness and announced his purpose with
great dignity, he would
be admitted to speak quickly, before the high council
could consider what
he might say, and so decide not to hear him. For the
same reason, Arm had
walked into town that morning alone, after only three
days at Marshrat's
hut, to address the first of the monthly council
meetings to occur after
his arrival. Marshrat knew well how the council would
receive Arm. Harvester,
the chief high councilor, and his cronies would try to
prevent Arm speaking
his embassy until they could learn what it was and
develop their response.
And there was no doubt what their intent would be, to
make sure that Arm
was heard by as few people as possible and taken
seriously by no one. They
would soon see Arm as a threat to all they thought
most important. Knowing
this, Marshrat wanted Arm to speak before it became
known that he was in
Marshtown and before Arm's name could be linked with
Arm and Marshrat had come to
new Marsh Lake
by night and had slept in the tall grass under the
stars, on a hill overlooking
Marshtown. Arm had never seen such a place. There were
huts of stone, and
some of wood, the sliced trunks of great trees. In the
night there was
much light, oil lamps in windows, and the torches or
lanterns of people
who walked among the huts. There was a kind of beauty
to such a town, laid
out in rows, with straight paths between the rows for
donkeys, carts, and
walkers. It seemed to him a great place indeed, even
But more beautiful to him
was this hillside.
This was the most lovely land he had seen since
leaving the swamp, for
this land seemed as it should be. Westward, beyond the
town was the reservoir,
a great lake, that caught in its face the light of
stars and the moon,
and brightened the hillside, making the town seem
small. Along the shore
of the lake were tall trees that seemed to guard it
from harm, marking
off its bright surface as separate from the land. The
smell of the water
crept up the hillside after they lay themselves down,
and drops of water
appeared at the ends of spears of grass. Arm thought
of home and of what
new and beautiful songs he might learn in this land.
Striding silently through
the streets in the
early morning, Arm had watched Marshrat's advice take
effect. The morning
work of the people there halted. It was strange to
Arm, unlike the welcome
a stranger would receive in the swamp. There children
ran to one with questions,
learning all about him or her and running to tell the
elders before the
elders could even look upon the new one. But then Arm
thought, "No one
so strange as I was to these people had come among us
in my time. Imagine
a sand-colored person with long hair on his head, but
nowhere else, wearing
smooth cloth covering most of his body, of bright
colors, perhaps sky blue
or leaf green or the red of burning berries. Imagine
this person walking
among us after our return from gathering. Would the
little ones run to
ask his name? Or would they perhaps gaze in wonder
from behind our kilts
or from within the shadows of our doors?"
The meeting house stood at
one side of a large
circular common ground. It was the most imposing
building facing the common,
towering above the grass-roofed huts and the few
stone, log and plank-sided
homes that circled around it. The building was
box-like, with two stories
beneath a wood-shingled four-peaked roof. In the upper
story were large
windows with glass in them. No other building stood so
tall, and few buildings
in the town had any glass windows, which could only be
had at great expense
from up-river, though there was talk of someday soon
making glass in Marshtown.
On the side facing the common, two large beams leaned
into each other to
form a great arch, within which a plain pair of tall
wooden outer doors
stood open, their outer corners resting on stone
blocks next to the arched
beams. Before the smaller, closed inner doors, colored
a bright red, stood
a man with a staff as long as himself. At its end was
an iron blade. He
was the keeper of the inner door, and it was of him
that Arm asked admission
to the council chamber.
The keeper brought him into
a grand room with
a high ceiling rising up in four dark corners. Windows
at the top of the
room, made it bright with morning sun. Encircling the
chamber was a second
floor gallery of dark polished wood, resting upon
carved wooden pillars,
with benches upon which people could sit in front of
the windows to listen
to the council meeting. He found himself for the first
time on a polished
wooden floor, and so he felt a little awkward on his
rough bare feet, and
the general grandeur of the room and its inhabitants
made him wonder whether
they would listen to so shabby a traveler as he,
without sandals or brightly
The council consisted of
forty men seated on
backed benches with red cushions. There were four
benches, two on each
side of the room, the one behind raised above the one
in front. At the
far end, behind a large table of polished golden wood,
with many papers
in neat piles upon it, sat the High Councilor, who
regulated their talk.
Though they were busily involved in discussion, all
sound gradually stopped
as the councilors gazed in astonishment upon the
strange being the keeper
was ushering into their presence.
When Arm entered the room,
there were perhaps
six spectators in the gallery -- one of whom was
Marshrat, at whom he glanced,
only to note his look enjoining no more glances in
that direction. After
his entrance the gallery began to fill, as all who had
seen Arm saunter
into their town and disappear into the council chamber
climbed the stairway,
shuffling and murmuring, to gratify their curiosity
and see the strange
event that was unfolding this day. At other times,
this room was used for
festivals and story-telling, and as the crowd entered,
the usually solemn
and quiet dignity of a council meeting took on more of
the air of a festival.
Feeling that the noise was
growing, Arm addressed
himself to the High Councilor in the same words he had
used with the keeper
of the door. This speech produced instant quiet inside
the chamber, though
people were still crowding into the gallery, and a
good crowd could be
seen and heard murmuring, stretching their necks
around the keeper who
had returned and stood in the door, with his staff
horizontal across it.
Into this comparative quiet, Harvester, the High
"Welcome, ambassador and arm
of IS. We, of
the High Council, honor our distinguished visitor.
"Ignorant as we were of your
coming, I regret
that we have made no proper preparation for you.
Therefore, I beg that
you will forgive my taking a few moments before you
address your embassy
to us to confer with my advisers."
Just as Marshrat had
predicted, Harvester called
to him two councilors from the benches and whispered
with them for a short
time. Then, after they returned to their benches, he
attempted to delay
"My advisers and I agree
that an embassy so
important as yours ought to be properly acknowledged
and received. Therefore,
let us welcome you today with feasting and ceremony,
and tomorrow let us
hear you speak of your mission."
"My embassy is of equal
importance to your
well-being as it is to mine. I would speak of it now,
if you please, that
you may begin from this moment to see into it and
apply your wisdom to
His advisers clearly opposed
this idea, wishing
to delay Arm's speaking to the whole council until
they could learn what
he would say. But they were unwilling to be too
obvious in their opposition,
especially as voices arose among members of the
council eager to hear this
stranger, their wonder and curiosity aroused. Voices
were raised in the
council and in the gallery. "Hear him! Let us know why
he comes and who
So Arm gained the chance to
speak before the
whole council and, therefore, before the whole town,
many of whom had filled
the gallery. Marshrat's advice had won him a first and
18. The Disappearance of Arm
From Arm's Chronicle of IS
When I first addressed the
high council of
Marshtown, I followed Marshrat's advice. I began with
myself and my journey,
telling of the swamp and of my walk across the lands
of pricklies, stones,
and dunes. This was, as Marshrat said, to establish my
reality in their
minds. So, they saw how their world and my world were
the southern waste. And they saw that my world was not
unlike theirs, a
world of different looking men who lived a different
life, but not much
different from their own.
Then, very briefly, I told
of my mission.
"At the beginning of the
last moon, IS, the
center of our life, spoke to me. IS said to me that
its life radiates from
the swamp, but that life comes to it from the whole
world, flows to it
as music through the waters of the world. IS said that
in half of the world,
a silence had grown, until there was almost no music
at all. And with this
silence had come a slowing of the water. When the
water stops altogether,
silence will be all. Then, slowly but surely, our
swamp will dry up and
die. Then we will die, and IS will die and, for a time
at least, the singing
of our world will come to an end. When singing stops,
all will be as dead.
"I have come, therefore, to ask you, who have power
over the water of
Marsh River, to restore its flow into the marsh. Let
the marsh try again
to come alive, and let the water sink into the marsh
so that it may flow
through the underground stream to our swamp. To do
this is to save our
lives, yours and mine, and more important, to save the
singing that makes
our lives real and full."
When I finished, there was
an uproar in the
meeting place. It seemed that all the people burst
into talk, chaotic talk
in which all expressed their opinions to each other.
There was no attempt
for some time to quiet and address the whole group.
Though I heard many
words, I could not tell what the people as a whole
might think of my message
or what they would do about it.
I looked toward Marshrat,
but his quiet face
told me nothing. He had said before that he could not
predict how the people
would respond. He knew that Harvester, the High
Councilor, and all who
were close to him would want my mission denied, and
that they would find
any means of denying it they thought would work. I
studied them now. They
were silent themselves, listening carefully to those
Harvester was as Marshrat
described the people
of Marshtown. His belly was big, looking as if he
carried a basket held
up under his robe of blue cotton by a broad leather
belt. He wore a red,
sleeveless linen jacket that would not close over that
belly. Though his
black and gray hair curled around his ears and onto
his shoulders, there
was none on top of his head, only shining, sand
colored skin. He had cut
off the hair of his face, as had most of the
I found a look in his eyes
that I saw among
many of the quieter men in that room. Then I thought
of it as a look of
thoughtfulness, of distance from the present talking,
but now I remember
it also as being empty of something. It was not that
they were absent from
the chaos of the talk they allowed to go on, for it
was clear that they
listened intently. Instead, they were absent from the
feelings being expressed.
To them, feelings in people were tools they could use,
not the mark of
their being of the same kind. This look in their eyes
was the look of people
who did not see the tie between their feelings and the
feelings of others.
Perhaps their own feelings were invisible to them, and
they thought of
themselves as without feelings. The longer I remained
in Marshtown, the
more terrifying that look became, until the day I
nearly went mad within
After much noise and
confusion, Harvester and
his advisers suddenly stood up together, as if they
had agreed on a time
in silence. When the room was quiet, Harvester spoke.
"You have spoken eloquently,
stranger, of your
fantastic home and impossible journey. The High
Council is surprised by
your sudden appearance and by a request that seems so
much against our
interests and that promises so little to gain. My
personal opinion is that
perhaps you should speak to certain medical men of my
acquaintance up the
river, for they may help you more than we can.
"Still, your appearance is
unique, and your
words are moving, and we would not act rashly.
"Therefore, I adjourn the
meeting of the council
until tomorrow morning. Until then the councilors and
I will visit privately
with the citizens, with each other, and with you.
Tomorrow morning, we
will meet again to consider your request. Now, Arm of
the Swamp, you shall
be a guest at my house."
Harvester came forward and
took my hand, leading
me carefully out of the meeting hall, where most of
the councilors and
citizens remained talking about me and my mission. He
took me to his home,
a large wooden building of many rooms and floors of
wood. There he offered
me food and rest, leaving me alone until he returned
Left alone, I wondered what
What were people saying about me and my mission? Would
they sing together,
listening to the songs to tell them how to sing?
Marshrat said they did
not sing. How would they know then what to do? How
could they discover
I wanted to speak with
Marshrat, but he had
warned me not to take note of him from the moment I
entered the village.
To be associated with him would weaken my mission.
I ate of the fruits and
breads, but not of
the meats left for my eating. My talks with Marshrat
had revealed that
the people of Marshtown ate animals. Though that was a
great wonder to
me, we had not talked of it in our short time. He had
said that because
he ate no flesh, he could offer me none. When I
wondered that anyone ate
flesh, he only said that it did not matter, then. As
soon as I smelled
the strange foods upon Harvester's table, I knew that
some were meats.
Though they did not repel me as I thought they might,
neither did they
attract me. I could find no appetite for such foods in
After eating, I lay upon a
soft pallet, wondering
at the place I had come to. Who were these people who
ate the flesh of
other animals? To eat of life, even the waterroot, was
natural. But the
difference between the plants and the animals is that
plants give us of
their surplus or give us themselves as food when they
complete their lives.
We do not kill them for our food. Even the birds give
us only their extra
eggs, always keeping two for themselves, to make
themselves over. And the
frogs do the same, keeping many more eggs. And among
these people, as I
learned later, there were animals that gave the
surplus of their mothers'
milk, a very good food. In such a land of richness,
why would anyone wish
to take the lives of animals and eat their flesh?
Surely this could only
be in a land of no singing, where the songs of the
other animals were not
For all the afternoon, I lay
upon my pallet, thinking a little of what people might
be saying of me.
Sometimes I sang quietly to myself -- a most lonely
thing -- some of the
songs of the swamp, to remind me of myself and of
At evening, I stood at a
that looked over a colorful garden, filled with many
kinds of flowers,
and over the roofs of other homes, toward the sunset,
deep and red. Harvester
entered the room quietly behind me and spoke.
"My garden is quite
beautiful, is it not? I
have carefully collected every variety of rose that
grows along Marsh River
and into the distant mountains. Would you walk with me
there while our
dinner is prepared?"
As we walked in the cooling
evening in this
place of beautiful odors and many colors, he
"Why have you come by
yourself, a single ambassador,
on a mission so important to your people?"
"No one of our people had
ever crossed the
dry lands. Others would have come with me, but IS
asked only me, and I
would not have others risk their lives on so difficult
"Then, you do not think
others will follow
"Who can say, High
Councilor, what others will
do? IS does not want the world to die. It may well
send others to follow
me if my message is not heard, or if it is forgotten.
But, of course, you
have heard my message, and such a message cannot be
I could not tell why
Harvester asked me such
questions, except to learn who I was and what we are
like here in the swamp.
My last reply made him quiet for some time, as he
stopped to tend a rose,
bright and pale golden as the moon in the fading
"Are you aware that we must
cease to use one
of the aqueducts, wasting years of labor and pain, if
we grant your request?"
"Surely that pain is past.
It is the pain of
now that we must stop. Because we have hurt in the
past, must we continue
to hurt now?"
"Do you understand the
consequences of our
ceasing to irrigate on the flat lands?"
"No, I understand little of
what you are doing.
I saw as I came that there are green fields on the
edges of the waste.
I talked there with a man who sees to the waters, and
he said that food
and fiber are grown there to be taken up the river. He
seemed to me a happy
man, tending the water and nourishing those fields. I
would be sad to cause
his unhappiness. But I look upon your hillsides,
watered from the same
river and think surely that man could continue his
labors here, less far
from his home, and in a more human land."
"The consequences are much
greater than that.
More than one man will be made unhappy if we let the
"I come from another place.
Though it is quite
different from this place of hills and grass, I can
see that our homes
are alike in one way. They are rich in food and
beauty. Are you so many
that you must grow food on the dry land where it would
not grow by itself?
And you have the new Marsh Lake as well, a moon upon
the earth. Are not
this new lake and the hills and the marsh, were it
alive again, enough
Harvester studied me quietly
for a moment.
We were just able to see each other clearly in the
glow of the new evening.
I saw that his face concealed rather than revealed his
thinking. He was
of those who keep themselves secret. We think such
people ill, and after
leaving them to themselves for a time, we sing our
songs of healing to
them, gathering outside their huts on the darkest
night. But in this land,
there were many such and no one thought them ill, and
no one sang to them.
As I looked at him, I was tempted to sing, and the
words came to my tongue,
though I made no sound. Perhaps had I sung then, we
might have gone around
Come, come into the darkness
dear, dark one.
The winking star has closed its
eye, and we
Come, come into the darkness dear,
Join your darkness with ours.
We are here.
You are there.
Come, come and make one darkness
Dear dark one, make one with us.
Come, come and make one darkness
These words were in my mind when he said we should go
in to eat. He
turned silently from me, and floated away, round like
a bush draped in
blue and red.
When, at his table, I ate no
meat, he was not
surprised. "You are of the marshrats I see."
I was surprised that he
should so quickly associate
me with my friend, for I had thought our meeting
unknown. Seeing my surprise,
he questioned me. "You know of our marshrats? Perhaps
you have met one
on your journey?"
I am not well able to say
that which is not,
and as you know, I have never been of those who hide
Marshrat's advice, I had tried, I thought with
success, to conceal my meeting
with him, for he warned me that this would work
against me. I saw that
Harvester had gained this information in some way, and
I saw no way of
concealing it now. Still, I thought it best to say
little, so I said only
that at the edge of the waste land, I had eaten with a
man called Marshrat.
Harvester said, "Now, I
think I see more deeply
into these events.
"I confess you have me
believing in your authenticity.
You really are not from among the men of the hills,
nor have you come from
the mountains. You have not disguised your face, and
your kilt was not
made from fibers we grow. But now I think I see how
you have come among
us. Still, it is remarkable."
I listened and puzzled. What
had I revealed?
He turned quietly to the bone of some bird from which
he gnawed away the
cooked flesh. Watching him drew the sweetness from the
berries I was sampling,
so that they tasted like old carrots, and I lost my
hunger. I waited for
him to speak again, and after wiping his fingers on a
cloth and drinking
from his wine glass, he did.
"Yes, it is quite clear to
me now. Marshrat,
and his cronies from the back hills have found you
somewhere, a lost wanderer
from a strange land, and have made you into their
tool. It is a brilliant
plot, better than I would expect from such idle poets
and hermits. Of course,
just finding you would give them the idea; there's
nothing so great in
that. But they have done it so well!"
I began to feel a kind of
was new to me then. When I felt it, I realized that it
had begun earlier,
when the meeting place had burst into chaotic babble
after I presented
my message. This strange feeling was one of not
belonging. I was no longer
there. I had been replaced by something else.
I don't mean that another
sat in my place at
the table. I remained and listened, but he talked to
himself as if I were
invisible, as if I had ceased to be there. My reality
had become unreal
to him. Instead, I was becoming the person or creature
he was inventing
in his fancy before my eyes. He was dreaming a new
person to inhabit my
flesh, and I had nothing to do with the shape that
person would take.
I saw that Harvester had
found a way to deny
my mission, that this way was in denying me. I
listened in wonder as he
"It's a clever trick,
indeed, for half the
town believes he really is an ambassador from the
fantastic swamp. But
the main idea is to get the marsh back and to prevent
the great expansion
of people into our valley.
"These selfish old-fashioned
coots are making
their last desperate effort to keep this valley an
ignorant backwater where
they can be vegetarian hermits in peace and quiet,
writing down their drivel,
weeping over the birds that flew away. By Carlo, they
are ignorant savages!"
Then he turned to me again,
speaking to me,
but now to the me he had in his head.
"I'm not sure what is best
to do with you.
Once I make clear to the council how you have come, I
think you'll be harmless
on the whole. The marshrats can take care of you. It
would be a mistake,
I think, to try to harm you, for there are those in
the town who will believe
you, no matter what we say. To hurt you would give
them a cause.
"Besides, I really do
believe you are a simple
stranger, and I cannot blame you for being taken in by
the riff-raff you
are likely to meet when first wandering into our
country. They were kind
to you, and you thought to help them.
"You had best return to
them, soon. But tonight
you must remain with me, and tomorrow you may come to
the council and even
speak again if you like, though I don't think you'll
With that, he rose from the
table, and bidding
me be comfortable in his house, he left to talk again
with his advisers.
There is a story we tell in
the swamp about
Mart who became invisible. Mart climbed a high palm in
quest of gum fruit
and, by accident, fell and hurt his head. For a long
time he could not
hear our songs. He could sing, and we could hear him,
but he heard neither
himself nor us. He could not sing with us. At first,
he joined us each
night at the fire. Then he stopped coming. We did not
know what to do.
He grew silent and then ill. We feared he would leave
us. We could not
sing our healing songs to him, though we sang them
One night as we invited him
to join us in darkness
behind the closed eye, he cried out loudly from inside
his hut. "Is someone
calling me?" Knowing he was weak with his illness, we
went in to him, and
from that night, he began to hear again, faintly at
first, then better,
though he always turned his left ear toward those who
spoke to him.
We tell this story because
of what Mart told
us of his imprisonment in silence. He said, "At first,
I would not believe
in silence. The songs were in my head. I knew my
brothers and sisters were
singing these songs. Then, the silence seemed to grow,
driving out the
melodies inside me and leaving a growing emptiness. I
began to believe
I was disappearing, that as the songs flowed out of me
so I was flowing out of the world. My brothers and
sisters, too, seemed
to fade until the fire would shine through them. One
day, I was no more
to be seen, and I could see no one. Silence was
complete, and I knew I
was dead. After I was dead a long time, I heard a tiny
voice calling me
to come back to life, and here I am."
19. Cast Out
In the council chamber on
the morning after
Arm's appearance, things happened as Harvester
predicted and planned. One
of the councilors, not Harvester or one of his main
advisers, told the
council he had learned Arm was a tool of the
marshrats. Arm, he said, was
a primitive humanoid, saved from the waste by those
malcontents who lingered
near it, deceived by them in his simplicity, and sent
to restore the useless
and mucky old marsh. An innocent victim, he deserved
pity and some kindness,
separated as he was from his kind, but his fantastic
story of a singing
god in paradise was the invention of the mad poets and
hermits of the back
hills. All knew that, in truth, the nameless God who
dreams in darkness
had spoken this world into being and feeds it from his
When those present again
burst into chaotic
talk, it was as if Arm had disappeared. Though there
must have been those
present who understood what was happening, there was
no interest here in
speaking with Arm. Around him was a mystic circle into
which no one would
enter. The part of the room he occupied had ceased to
exist, and people
would walk around it as if they believed they were
walking in a straight
A stranger in the clothing
of a hill farmer
took Arm's wrist and led him silently from the
chamber. They walked in
silence out of the town, past the dam, and down into
the old marsh, until
they found Marshrat sitting on the bank of the pool of
IS, where with only
a silent look at Marshrat, the stranger departed.
Marshrat was watching
the waterroot waving in the stream. It had attached
itself to the bank,
and it rippled in the slight current. He had not come
to the meeting, having
heard around the town how it would go. He had returned
home sadly in the
dark, and he had sat all night before his hut,
mourning the death of his
hope for the marsh. At dawn he was drawn to the pool,
the small center
of life in this dying world.
So again, they sat through
the remains of an
afternoon, in the shady grove beside the trickle of
Marsh River. They spoke
little. Arm had no idea what to do next except to
return to the swamp.
He had done what he could. Perhaps IS would send
another more capable.
Perhaps there were other things to try.
At sunset, Marshrat stirred.
"We must not yet
despair. I know there is little hope. The people of
the valley grow fat
by selling the river, and they dream of growing
fatter. They dream of many
people coming to live here. They see much wealth of
trade. Every man will
have a house and garden like Harvester's. There will
be inns and great
shops in Marshtown, and it will become a city such as
River Falls at the
foot of the distant mountains. These hills will be
covered with people,
and the ones who are here now will sell them
everything, and in this way,
will secure wealth for themselves and their children.
"But such wealth will be
only a great weight
to bend their shoulders to the earth. And so bent over
their fat bellies,
they will be like the worms that see only the earth
that they eat.
"People have eyes to follow
the flight of the
crane out toward the unknown lands and on to the
stars. People have ears
to hear the egret call out the linking song that comes
from the marsh and
ascends to the stars. With their heads buried in
earth, the big bellies
will see only the granules and pebbles of their bodies
and will hear only
the streams and rumblings of blood and gas in their
guts. So shut up, while
their bodies fatten, their souls will shrink, until
they are only granules
and gas, pebbles and blood.
"Already they don't know or
feel what they
Arm listened in weary
silence to Marshrat's
"I confess I don't know what
we can do, but
we must continue to try."
Arm suggested, "I suppose we
could feed the
swamp were we to break the aqueducts." This seemed a
simple idea to Arm.
If a thing caused pain and did no good, then it was
easy to stop that thing,
if it could be stopped.
Marshrat said this was not
so easy. The aqueducts
were strong. One person could go in the night and
close the gates, but
the next morning this would be discovered and the
gates reopened. If this
were done several times, the gates would be guarded.
If the gates were
damaged, they would soon be repaired, and then
guarded. The aqueducts could
not be stopped unless people's minds were changed. And
how does one talk
to a big belly with pebbles in its ears and sand in
That night, before returning
hut, they made a new plan. They would continue to
talk, telling Arm's tale
to all the people of the back hills. They would talk
to any who would listen.
They would try to become one people for the marsh, and
together, they would
try to think of a way to restore it and to save the
swamp and the world.
Having even such a small idea, knowing no more where
it would lead than
he knew his way across the waste land when he left the
swamp, Arm knew
that for IS he must give more time. To return with the
word of death was
For thirty-six days, until
the high summer
festival, Marshrat and Arm packed food baskets and
walked into the hills
and along the edges of the hills, speaking to those
who lived on the borders.
Often on warm evenings they found ourselves returned
to the pool of IS
to rest and talk of their adventures. During these
walks in the hills,
Arm discovered the people of the Marsh River country,
and among them, Peachtree,